Where I Stand
Do Transgender People Exist?
In 2015, I became the first duly ordained Southern Baptist minister to officiate a legal same sex wedding. That led to hundreds of Facebook “friend” requests and other efforts by lgbtq people to enter into relationships with me, mostly but not exclusively virtual.
A partial outgrowth of that explosion of recognition by gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender identifying people, was a book I published in 2017 called Rainbow in the Word: LGBTQ Christians’ Biblical Memoirs. At that time, I thought “transgender” was another type of gay or lesbian, an inborn, immutable reality.
I stand by the book and all the memoirs in it. Nonetheless, my thinking has changed. After reading more about it, thinking more about it, and engaging with “transgender” as a political, medical, therapeutic, and journalism issue, I realized I had been wrong. If I had written it today, for example, I would not have defined, in the “glossary of terms”, such ideas as “cisgender” which no longer make sense to me.
What especially changed my thinking was encountering the widespread idea that children are capable of determining that they have been born in the wrong body. A corollary to that mistaken idea is that children are capable of consenting to irreversible puberty blocking hormones, reverse sex hormones, and surgeries. Not only is this a reckless, harmful idea, it is one which challenges the very idea of children, i.e. they are not miniature adults. It challenges, too, the very idea of childhood, i.e. that childhood is a time for exploration while being protected by adults.
It also seems clear to me that children did not come up with these ideas organically. They did not come up with them on their own. Nor did their parents, their counselors, their pastors, or their teachers. They learned it from somewhere. My instincts told me to “follow the money”. They told me to ask, “Who benefits?”
Clearly, it is not the children themselves who benefit. They are being robbed of a meaningful puberty, of the chance to realize they are gay or straight boys and gay or tomboy girls, and robbed of healthy body parts with no way to undo what has been done. The parents are being emotionally blackmailed with what became a standard therapist’s pro-transitioning question, “Would you rather have a living son/daughter or a dead daughter/son?” They are being robbed of the ability to be their child’s primary guide and advocate. They are being robbed of the ability legally to say “no” to sex destroying procedures on their children.
Do I think there are people who have suffered some trauma which prompts them to want to change their sexual identity? I do, but I think it is rare. I think that trauma as causation is far different from an inborn trait as causation. Do I think they benefit from hormones and surgeries? Possibly. That avoids the question, though, of whether doctors, nurses, and hospitals should provide those hormones and surgeries without truly compelling reasons, if at all.
I founded this podcast because I believe that children are being irrevocably injured by an ideology and by the greed of doctors and medical institutions which have decided children are a market and who have revoked their promise to “do no harm.”
Because children do not exist in a vacuum, the podcast also explores such related issues as legislation, lawsuits, the courts, school policies, medical standards of care, and prevalent co-morbidities including autism.
My hope is that we all become more educated about this sensitive subject.
← RE: Moving Parts