Blog

The Politics of “Smile”

Ellin Jimmerson, September, 2018

I would suspect every woman reading this post has been told some version of the smile motif at least once if not multiple times in her life. I would suspect few of the men reading this post have ever had it said to them, had the demand behind the motif placed on them, or had relational expectations reinforced by hearing of the motif.

That is part of it, too. One population experiences and understands; another one does not even know of the existence of the phenomenon much less have any personal experience with it.

Women and men say to girls, "You'd be so much prettier if you smiled." An observation with broader social implications.

Men say, "Give us a smile." An order. With intimate relationship implications.

I don't like it when I hear someone say "You'd be so much prettier if you smiled." I become livid when I hear, "Give us a smile," especially when a man says it to a young girl.

Because what is behind the smile expectation is that we girls and women make people anxious or even angry when we don't smile. Our faces are continually being watched. So there is that aspect to "You'd be so much prettier" that comes from a place of "Life would be so much easier for you if you smiled more. Put people at ease. Because they are watching your face. Because they see reflected in your face their own insecurities, their own self-doubts.

And the expectation is that you are here for a particular purpose: them.

The gaze.

Because women have only three emotional speeds, as we hear over and over and over—mad, sad, glad. If you look (per the gaze) like you're sad or if you look like you're mad, you must be sad because of me (its about me) or mad at me (its about me) or glad because of me. You're supposed to be glad because of me. Give us a smile. Give us a damn smile! Bitch.

The unsmiling female face has even been anointed with this name:

Resting Bitch Face.

And God forbid we should ever be seen driving around town squinting because of the sun. Bitch. Or seen lost in our thoughts not even noticing you. Bitch.

There are various ways to express "you'd be so much prettier." I hear this a lot. I mean a lot. Mostly from women: "You'd be so much more effective if you were not so forceful." You bitch. "You intimidate me." Bitch. "Why don't you lighten up?” Bitch. You make me uncomfortable. I'm uncomfortable and its your fault.

No, its not my fault. Its not my fault that you are so insecure that you need my face to soothe you.

Its not my fault that when I appeal to your conscience, to your obligations as an American, as a human being, that your instinct is to appeal to my vanity. To my neediness. Which I do have, but not to anywhere near the degree you'd like me to have.

And hear this well. There is no part of me that is capable of smiling when I'm trying to get you to care about migrant deaths or pregnant women working on the 4th of July in 105 degree heat while trying to avoid ICE's gaze or persuade you that your boy Obama put concentration camps on the southern border well before Trump or I keep trying and keep trying to make you care about the fact that your girl Hillary is a fake feminist who set up the conditions in which rape became an epidemic in Honduras and you say you care but you don't care because what you really care about is your social club activism and when I don't smile when I can't smile you realize full well that you're about the connection the mutual masturbatory party and not them. You don't care about the women and boys raped in Honduras or on the border. Why don't you just say it? Just come out and say it? Instead you say,

"You'd be so much prettier if you'd smile. Give us a smile dammit!" Bitch.

Listen and listen well. If you want to have some part in ripping apart rape culture, you need to stop demanding any little girl give you a smile. Think about the totality of what you are saying to her. Think about all the ways you convey to her, "You'd be so much prettier if you'd smile" and stop. Stop. She did not fight her way out of the womb in order to spend a lifetime adjusting to rape culture. Don't teach her to adjust.

Smiles are good. See my picture attached to this post? I'm a big smiler. I smile and laugh a lot. I make an effort to smile at the people behind the counter. I smile when I want to.

But don't you ever TELL me to smile.

← All Politics & Culture