
Sexual Assault: Truth or Dare
My intention is to keep pushing for an understanding of what sexual assault is and what rape culture is. In the aftermath of Dr. Christine Blasey Ford’s testimony concerning now Supreme Court Justice, Brett Kavanaugh, there have been an avalanche of “survivor” stories from women, and men, detailing their own experiences. It is imperative, if we are to address and eliminate sexual abuse, sexual assault, and rape as an everyday occurrence, that we begin to understand what it is.
In a Facebook post, a man asked in a way I believed to be sincere whether he had been a sexual predator or had committed sexual assault in the following situation.
When he was in the 7th grade, he and a large group of other 7th graders had gone to a spend-the-night party. There were girls and boys there. The parents left. After the parents left, there was a decision made to play Truth or Dare, a game involving telling the truth in answer to a question or accepting a dare. There are consequences if you don't accept the dare. It is a game about "embarrassment tolerance".
The man posting the question said that he was dared to kiss a certain girl. He said he "had to kiss her." In his post, he said that he had understood that she did not want him to kiss her. He kissed her anyway.
I entered the conversation because I thought he was genuinely trying to understand whether he had done the wrong thing. I said that kissing her against her will did not make him a sexual predator, but it was sexual assault. That did not mean, I said, that made him a terrible person, but that, yes, in the 7th grade he had committed sexual assault.
He and a few of his friends (men) began to challenge me as was their right. All their comments were designed to skirt around the fact, which he himself had disclosed, that she had indicated she did not want him to kiss her. And he did it anyway.
He said, well you have to understand social mores were different 30 years ago. I responded that 30 years ago when a girl indicated she did not want you to kiss her that meant you were not to kiss her.
I kept emphasizing that she indicated she did not want him to kiss her, and he did it anyway. That is sexual assault. It is not the degree to which Christine Blasey Ford was sexually assaulted, I said, but it was a sexual assault.
I gave them Black's Law Dictionary definition of an actionable assault (an assault for which one can wind up in court): the "threat or use of [the threat of] force on another that causes that person to have a reasonable apprehension of . . . offensive contact". But it was actually more than “assault"; it was "assault and battery." Because the moment he touched her, he had committed "battery"—i.e. he made actual physical contact.
To ward off any would be challengers on the finer legal aspects: I'm not a lawyer with a potential client. I'm a woman who has a pretty good grasp of what rape culture is, and I'm trying to push that conversation along.
My point was to emphasize that "assault" and “battery” have agreed upon definitions. Assault involves “the threat of force" on the part of one or more parties, "apprehension" on the part of another or others, and "offensive contact.” The crime of “battery” is making actual physical contact.
It was sexual assault and battery, I said, because in our culture a kiss on the mouth has sexual implications. Which is why I don't go around kissing random men on the mouth. I kiss my husband on the mouth. Period. Full stop. End of story.
That was the point of the "dare". The dare wasn't to shake her hand or enter into a staring contest. I'm guessing she would not have been apprehensive about a hand shake or a staring game. The dare was to kiss her on the mouth. Which she indicated she did not want, and he did it anyway. The point, which each of them well understood, was that the dare involved a sexual or sexualized act.
Then came the grand litany of minimizing efforts from his men friends to indicate to this man that he had done nothing wrong.
Truth or Dare became "spin the bottle": come on, Ellin, it was just a game of "spin the bottle." (An innocent game.) Language games. Spin the Bottle does sound more innocent, I'll grant you that. Which is the purpose of repeatedly calling it "spin the bottle." A diversionary tactic. A language move. No, it was not "spin the bottle" it was Truth or Dare.
Next diversionary tactic?
"She knew what she was getting into." Really? When she was dropped off at the party, this 12 year old girl, she knew the parents would leave? She knew the night would turn into "Truth or Dare"? She knew some boy would force a kiss onto her mouth? She knew that? Right. This 12 year old girl.
Next?
"But he is gay. He could not have wanted to." Its actually not about what he wanted. That's pretty much the central theme here. Its about what she wanted and that she didn't want it, and he knew it, and he did it anyway.
Next?
"I had to." No, you didn't have to. Someone put a gun to your head?
Next?
"If everything is sexual assault, nothing is sexual assault." No. Only sexual assault is sexual assault. (We’re getting into "boys will be boys territory. Is that not clear? In my head.)
Next?
This is what rape culture is. It begins early in our children's cultural education. It has culturally agreed upon "normalizing" rituals. It involves all sorts of tactics by which men, and sometimes women, encourage one another not to see what they did for what they did. Thereby blocking any ability they might have to confess, to repent, to apologize, to attempt to make things right, to change their point of view. And their actions. Thereby blocking our collective ability to move into deeper discussions about rape culture.
If we cannot even understand and admit that kissing a 12 year old girl who indicated she did not want your mouth on her mouth and you put your mouth on her mouth anyway is sexual assault, how in the name of all that's holy do we expect Justice Kavanaugh to admit that the horrendous thing he did to Christine Blasey Ford was a sexual assault? Why do we expect that of him?
If I cannot admit I stole a nickel, why would I expect someone else to admit they stole a dollar?
We have got to have serious conversations about rape culture—what it is, who participates in it, when it starts, and how the game is rigged. I think we can do that if we will.
← All Politics & Culture