The Mothers: No More Tears , by Valarie James and colleagues, Installation, Pima County Community College, Arizona
The Mothers: No More Tears , by Valarie James and colleagues, Installation, Pima County Community College, Arizona
Blog

Why Don't They Come Legally?

Ellin Jimmerson, 2013

It's a fair question, don't you think?
Why don't they come legally? You'd be surprised how many people, including migrant advocates, cannot answer this question. I think part of the reason is that so many of us have shied away from the whole concept of illegal. However we think about the word "illegal," we need to be able to answer this question.

The answer is so simple. They don't come legally because the United States doesn't allow people without title to land or significant amounts of money to come to the US legally if they are from Latin America, Africa, and most parts of Asia.

As immigration attorney, Klari Tedrow, says in The Second Cooler, "For purposes of immigration, people from Latin America are treated quite differently from Canadians."

The United States has two separate legal entry systems. And those systems are racially, socially, and ethnically encoded. By that I mean the US has an institutional preference for people from Canada and Western Europe—people who are perceived to be white, middle class, and Western in their religion and world-view.

They can come to the US legally with only a passport. Sometimes, they don't even have to have a passport. They just fill out paperwork on the plane. There is an assumption that Canadians and Western Europeans, for the most part, come to the US temporarily. The assumption is that they will come as tourists, for example, or to attend a family wedding, and will return to their home countries after a brief stay

But people who come from Latin America, Africa, and most parts of Asia have to have a visa to come to the US. They have to qualify. There is a presumption that if they are allowed to come, they will not go home. And the US wants them to go home.

So they have to fit into one of about 85 rigidly constructed boxes. They have to demonstrate that they have strong ties to their home countries. In other words, they have to assure the US government that they will go home.

There are two qualifications that apply to all 85 categories. They have to have title to land and they have to have significant amounts of money. This discriminates at the outset against indigenous people, for example those who have come unlawfully by the hundreds of thousands from southern Mexico and central America. Many of them are traditional or "peasant" farmers who live on communally-held lands. Not having a title to any land, they are disqualified before they have an opportunity to apply for a visa. By the same token, many indigenous people and many small business people cannot accumulate the necessary quantities of money.

Why don't they get in line? The answer is so simple. They don't get in line because for them there is no line to get into in order to come legally.

← All Immigration